Commercial Law, 2011 Bar — Question 62

MULTIPLE CHOICE

P, a sales girl in a flower shop at the Ayala Station of the Metro Rail Transit (MRT) bought two tokens or tickets, one for her ride to work and another for her ride home. She got to her ower shop where she usually worked from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. At about 3 p.m., while P was attending to her duties at the flower shop, two crews of the MRT got into a fight near the ower shop, causing injuries to P in the process. Can P sue the MRT for contractual breach as she was within the MRT premises where she would shortly take her ride home? A) No, since the incident took place, not in an MRT train coach, but at the MRT station. B) No, since P had no intention to board an MRT train coach when the incident occurred. C) Yes, since she already had a ticket for her ride home and was in the MRTs premises at the time of the incident. D) Yes, since she bought a round trip ticket and MRT had a duty while she was at its station to keep her safe for her return trip.

You can write freely without an account. Sign in to reveal the suggested answer and track your progress.